Team #312Truck
Analysis of aluminum vs steel truck body repair costs, examining specialized equipment requirements, technician training needs, facility certifications, and long-term maintenance considerations for fleet operators.
When choosing between aluminum and steel truck bodies, repair costs and infrastructure requirements play a crucial role in the total cost of ownership. While aluminum offers superior fuel efficiency and corrosion resistance, it demands significantly higher repair investments, specialized equipment, and extensive technician training that can increase costs by 40-145% compared to steel repairs.
Aluminum truck body repairs require substantially higher investments due to specialized equipment requirements, technician training needs, and limited certified repair facilities. However, aluminum bodies offer superior fuel efficiency and corrosion resistance that can offset higher repair costs through reduced maintenance and improved fuel economy over the vehicle’s lifespan.
Aluminum truck body repair presents unique technical challenges that differentiate it from steel repair. Aluminum’s high thermal conductivity and low melting point can cause burnthrough, warping, or lack of fusion during repairs. The material requires specialized welding techniques, with pulse transfer mode welding being mandatory for aluminum-intensive vehicles.
Repairing aluminum panels is not the same as repairing steel. Removing a dent in an aluminum panel is different because the material is stronger than steel, and requires special skill, welding materials and other equipment. Unlike steel, aluminum doesn’t have “memory” – it won’t return to its original shape after being damaged, making traditional hammer-and-dolly repair techniques ineffective.
Steel truck bodies, while heavier, offer more straightforward repair processes. Steel has 2.5 times the density of aluminum and demonstrates better impact resistance. Steel welding is the simplest form of welding and is easy for beginners to pick up. Steel repairs can often be performed by standard body shops without specialized equipment requirements.
Current market data shows significant cost variations for aluminum repairs. The auto body shop told the Edmunds team that it would cost $120 an hour, which is double the cost of steel body repair, to smooth out the aluminum. It took over 20 hours to complete the repairs, and the final bill was over $4,000. That is over 75 percent higher than fixing a steel body.
However, industry averages suggest certified aluminum repair shops charge an average rate of $92 per hour, with some facilities reporting charges only a few dollars more per hour than their regular repair rates.
Steel truck bodies are approximately one-third less costly than aluminum truck bodies for repairs. Steel repairs typically cost less because they don’t require specialized equipment or extensive technician training. The repair process is more standardized and widely available across most body shops.
Key Cost Factors:
Aluminum repair facilities must meet stringent requirements including:
Aluminum and steel do not mix. Should they come together during the repair process, the corrosion damage to the aluminum vehicle components could be irreversible. This requires completely separate work spaces and tool sets.
Steel repair shops require standard equipment and can use conventional welding techniques. Most existing body shops can perform steel repairs without major equipment investments, making steel repairs more accessible and cost-effective.
The investment in aluminum repair training is substantial. Training costs for one OEM aluminum repair program can range from $1,125 to an eye-watering $32,500 with travel costs. Technician investment for training and certification for multiple OEM brands averages $65,000. Total investment in training and facility to achieve multi-brand certification status ranges from $125,000 to $250,000.
Steel repair technicians require basic welding certifications that are widely available and less expensive than aluminum-specific training. The learning curve is less steep, and certification programs are more accessible.
About 10% of repair facilities in North America are fully certified to repair aluminum. This limited network creates challenges for fleet operators who need convenient access to qualified repair services. Ford is the major exception to part restrictions, having no limitations on aluminum body panel access.
Steel repair services are widely available, with most body shops capable of performing steel truck body repairs without specialized certification requirements.
Aluminum truck bodies require less annual maintenance due to their natural corrosion resistance. With proper care, an aluminum truck body can last up to 30 years. The material’s resistance to rust eliminates many long-term maintenance concerns, particularly important for fleets operating in harsh weather conditions or coastal areas.
Steel truck bodies require regular maintenance to prevent rust and corrosion. Steel is prone to rust and corrosion unless properly maintained, and this ongoing maintenance requirement can increase total cost of ownership over time.
Aluminum welding requires addressing several challenges including proper joint preparation, feed ability issues, heat management, and puddle control. The material’s naturally occurring oxide layer must be properly cleaned to prevent fusion issues and porosity. Since aluminum is sensitive to heat, an auto body repair shop will use specialized tools and techniques to avoid the risk of corrosion.
Steel welding utilizes standard MIG, TIG, or stick welding processes that are familiar to most technicians. Steel welding is often used in high-volume production because of its high accuracy and repeatability.
Aluminum-bodied vehicles are about 6% of the marketplace for new vehicles. This growing adoption is driving increased demand for certified aluminum repair facilities, though current capacity significantly exceeds the current level of need.
The transportation industry’s focus on weight reduction and fuel efficiency continues to drive aluminum adoption. However, repair infrastructure development must keep pace with market demand to ensure adequate service availability.
When evaluating aluminum vs steel truck bodies, consider:
While aluminum truck bodies offer significant operational advantages including fuel efficiency and corrosion resistance, they require substantially higher repair investments. Fleet operators must weigh the higher initial repair costs and infrastructure requirements against the long-term benefits of reduced maintenance and improved fuel economy.
The decision between aluminum and steel truck bodies shouldn’t be based solely on initial repair costs. Fleet operators must weigh the higher initial repair costs and infrastructure requirements against the long-term benefits of reduced maintenance and improved fuel economy. The decision should consider both the availability of certified repair facilities in operational areas and the total cost of ownership over the vehicle’s lifespan.
For fleets operating in harsh environments or prioritizing fuel efficiency, aluminum’s long-term benefits may justify the higher repair infrastructure investment. However, operations with limited access to certified aluminum repair facilities or tight repair budgets may find steel bodies more practical for their immediate needs.
Ready for a quote? Submit your information for a risk-free, no-commitment request today.
"Every off-season, we turn to 312 to refresh our fleet. They sandblast and repaint dozens of frames, trailers, and specialty paving equipment so everything is ready to hit the road again. Their speed and consistency have never let us down, and the quality of work speaks for itself."
"For over 20 years, the Patel family [312's owners] has worked alongside Enterprise Rentals, managing thousands of repairs of all sizes. Their deep knowledge of the collision industry—especially fleet-specific repairs—makes them a trusted resource in keeping our vehicles road-ready."
"Our business turns old shipping containers into mobile bars and quick-serve restaurants—we needed a paint partner who understands precision. 312 Truck’s marine-grade coatings match our brand colors with a flawless finish every time. Their attention to detail exceeds our clients' high expectations."
"312 Truck has been a reliable partner for our vehicle maintenance centers in the Midwest. Their team has helped with everything from Promaster vans to full-size trailers. One of the key reasons we continue to trust them is their excellent communication—keeping us informed throughout."
"Although we handle minor collision work in-house, when it comes to paint, 312 Truck is our go-to. Their pricing is among the most competitive in the Chicagoland area—often half of what others charge while still delivering high-quality results. They’ve been a valuable extension of our team."
"Keeping our fleet in top shape is a priority, and we need a partner that operates with speed and efficiency. 312 Truck has been instrumental in helping maintain our delivery vehicles—everything from mechanical work to heavy collision and cosmetic repairs for hundreds of our units every year."
"Our garbage trucks endure a lot of wear and tear—from accident damage to rust buildup. 312 Truck handles everything from structural repairs to repainting and de-branding before resale. Their expertise in durable, wear-resistant coatings keeps our fleet looking sharp against the elements."
